Recording is by hand, because the method depends on it
Monely does not connect to your bank. That is a decision, and there is an argument behind it.
An app that only pulls from the bank shows you what the bank already shows: the same statement, in a nicer screen. A list assembled by someone else changes nothing, because you took no part in making it. What turns an amount into awareness is the gesture of recording it, the two seconds in which you look at the number and decide where it belongs.
There is also a distinction that dissolves the apparent contradiction with WhatsApp. The awareness comes from the gesture. The bureaucracy of six taps to log a coffee is a different thing, and the bureaucracy is what makes people give up in the second week. A good tool keeps the gesture and cuts the bureaucracy, which is exactly what recording by message does: you say what you spent, and it is in.
The argument is the founder’s, in Chapter 3 of the book Cinco Minutos por Dia, in the section on why recording by hand is the remedy and not the defect. About the book (in Portuguese)
The target is your income, not a category
Monely has no spending cap per category. A cap is laborious to keep: it asks for a decision at every entry, and when the food cap runs out on the 20th, what stops is not the spending, it is the recording.
The same need is answered from the other end, and the other end holds up better:
- Income goals. You set the share of the month’s income that goes to investment, to shared expenses and to personal spending. The base is the income, so the target moves with it.
- Necessary and Desirable. Personal spending splits between what you need and what you want, each side with its own target share.
- The mark comes from the subcategory, set once. Every entry inherits it, so there is no decision to take at the moment of recording, which is precisely where the category cap dies in practice.
- Investment goals. A target amount tied to an account, with a progress bar, for whatever you are building towards.
The question from the book sums the whole thing up: “do I need this, or do I just want it?”